Tuesday, March 17, 2009

March Madness Round 2! The Whedonverse Character Tournament

So if you're just stumbling on to this now, you're right on time for Round 2 of this "March Madness" tourney - Whedon style. It's been designed to find the best/fan-favorite character of the entire Whedonverse (Buffy, Angel, Firefly and Dr. Horrible). Don't blame us if the choices are crazy, they were random at first but now are the result of your picks. From now on it's the "best of the best" and I know I'm scared.

Most of the last part were blow-outs. With the exception of maybe Connor vs. Lindsey (Lindsey won) they were all pretty one-sided. In fact, We finally had the first all out sweep in which Anya was victorious over Adam 50-0. This enraged Michelle since Buffy's match wasn't the same (Kendra managed 2 votes against her.) I think it has more to do with Adam's lameness than anything else. Here is the full list of winners:

The Mayor 36 to Simon 14; Wesley 37 to Joyce 13; Connor 18 to Lindsey 32; Anya 50 to Adam 0;
Buffy 48 to Kendra 2; Inara 40 to Moist 8; Illyria 35 to Dawn 14; Andrew 39 to Whistler 11

A few stats if you're into number geekery: As far as shows go, BtVS is winning since it retained 52% of it's original characters. Dr. Horrible is in 2nd place there, holding on to 2 of the 4 that were placed in round 1. Angel held on to 46% and Firefly is last as they lost quite a bit of their team and only have 44% left. Come on Browncoats! Don't get a jelly-belly on us now.

Finally, and most importantly, here are the next pairings which are for the first part of Round 2 (ending in 3 days - Thurs March 19th at 11:59 pm EST.) Just like always, if you want to play leave your choices in the comments section of this post!

The Sunnydale Region:

Oz vs. River







Jenny Calendar vs. Malcolm Reynolds







Faith vs. Spike (another could've been hot couple..check them out!)






Darla vs. Ethan Rayne (Ethan's still hangin with the big guys, huh?)





The Serenity Region:

Xander Harris vs. Charles Gunn (who will take it??)







Winifred "Fred" Burkle vs. The Master







Willow Rosenberg vs. Tara MaClay (I know, I know.)






Principal Robin Wood vs. Captain Hammer (Wood meet Hammer! Oh, that sounded both innocent and dirty at the same time.)



If your curious to see the entire bracket so far, click here to enlarge:


182 comments:

Tara said...

Re: Zacki and the whole Angelus/Angel thing - Sorry if there is confusion, we actually did discuss this once upon a time when we decided the characters. It's weird b/c we separated Fred and Illyria...but if we separated Angel from Angelus then we'd have to separate Spike from Souled!Spike and then it's a whole thing. So yes, you can lump the Vamps with Souls together with their evil counterparts for voting purposes.

When is someone going to name their band Vamps with Souls? Come on already!

Ok, on to my torturous picks. Some of these were extremely difficult for me. I'm not even going to bother explaining b/c I don't even understand the explanations:

The Sunnydale Region:
River
Malcolm Reynolds
Faith (they are so frickin' similar!)
Darla

The Serenity Region:
Charles Gunn
Fred
Tara
Captain Hammer

Cindy (Shutterbug0324) said...

Wow. *sigh* This is a toughie.

-Oz
-Malcolm
-Spike
-Darla
-Xander (poor charles)
-Fred
-Willow (that is just...wrong)
-Captain Hammer

I really do need to start back to my buffy marathon. 7 seasons for probably the 10th full time

Anonymous said...

River
Jenny
Spike (why oh why do you make me choose!)
Darla
Xander
The Master
Willow (srsly, this is starting to not be fun)
Hammer

B.E. Earl said...

Sunnydale Region
River
Mal
Spike (damn that was difficult)
Darla

Serenity Region
Xander
Fred
Willow (ouch!)
Robin Wood...barely.

Anonymous said...

-River
-Jenny (I like them both; I'll just vote for Capt. Hammer)
-Faith (I changed this so many times)
-Darla

-Xander
-Fred
-Tara
-Capt. Hammer


*zarine*

Iceeh said...

Wow, this voting round is pretty torturous. D:

The Sunnydale Region
-Oz
-Malcom Reynolds
-Faith (She's one of my favorite characters ever!)
-Darla (Bitchy blonde vamps FTW!)

The Serenity Region
-Xander (I maybesortakinda have an eyepatch fetish...)
-Fred
-Tara (;akelt;jkdfs -keyboard seizure- This one was freakin' painful!)
-Captain Hammer

Van Stuard said...

-Oz
-Mal
-Faith (oof)
-Darla
-Xander
-Fred
-Willow (sigh)
-Hammer

buffyslayergal said...

River
Mal
Spike
Ethan

Xander
Fred
Tara
Hammer

Alexiness said...

River
Malcom Reynolds
Faith
Darla

Charles Gunn
Fred
Tara
Captain Hammer

Gwen said...

Oz
Jenny
Faith
Darla

Xander
The Master
Tara
Captain Hammer

luciarosa said...

Sunnydale:
Oz
Captain Mal (perhaps this will be another slam dunk?)
Spike
Darla!

Serenity:
Gunn
Fred!!!
Willow (but as others have already pointed out, this is just mean)
Captain Hammer!!!

Joao Santos said...

My vote:

Sunnydale Region:
- River
- Malcom Reynolds
- Faith

Serenity Region:
- Xander harris
- Fred
- Willow
- Captain Hammer

zooey said...

.River
.Mal
.Spike
.Darla
.Xander
.Fred
.Willow
.Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

Sunnydale Region:
Oz - Love the guy!
Mal - I really didn't like Jenny.
Spike - This was so hard! I went with Spike purely as I think he had more fun moments.
Ethan - Darla's voice just grated on me.

Serenity Region:
Xander - another tricky one! But I am loyal to Buffy over Angel.
Fred - Although I did like the Master as a big bad.
Willow - HARD! but I only really liked Tara in s6 (when she got a personality).
Captain Hammer - Not keen on Wood!

Some hard ones there!

Zagreus said...

The Sunnydale Region:
River
Mal
Faith
Ethan

The Serenity Region:
Xander
The Master
Willow
Captain Hammer

Lizzy said...

SUNNYDALE:
River
Mal
Spike
Darla

SERENITY:
Xander
Fred
Tara
Hammer

Steph said...

Sunnydale:
Oz
Mal
Spike
Darla

Serenity:
Xander
Fred
Willow (It's the redhead solidarity kicking in.)
Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

River
Malcolm
Faith
Ethan
Xander
Fred
Willow
Wood

elaine said...

River
Malcolm
SPIKE, I can not believe how many people are voting for Faith, this was not a hard choice for me, SPIKE RULES

Darla
Xander
Master
Willow
Capt Hammer

Zacki said...

The Sunnydale Region:
*Oz (Loved his character, plus Seth Green rules)

*Malcolm Reynolds (Jenny wasn't that great)

*Faith (Easy choice for me. Loved evil Spike and his character kind of went downhill for me even though he did have many fun moments)

*Darla (Opposed to Spike, Darla's character got better as she came back in Angel)

The Serenity Region:
*Xander Harris (Easy choice, one of my favorite characters)

*Fred (Another easy choice)

*Willow Rosenberg

*Captain Hammer

marveldenton said...

River- this was the hardest pick for me

Mal- Captain Tightpants rules!

Spike- another tough one

Darla- I didn't vote for her in the first round and I did vote for Ethan but Darla I do like Darla better than Ethan

Xander- he was funnier and had a deeper character

Master- never a fan of Fred

Willow- battle of the les witches, Willow gets the vote cuz she went all veining and Tara didn't

Hammer- funny wins out again for me

Anonymous said...

River (Oz was OK but River kicked ass)
Jenny
Faith (this one was hard)
Darla
Xander
Fred
Tara (much harder, but Tara was sacrificed once to make Willow "awesome" so I'm not gonna)
Capt. Hammer (he's so funny!)

Hombrewolf said...

River
Jenny Calendar
Spike
Darla

Xander
Fred
(Tara vs Willow? come on!!)... Well, I'll say Willow
Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

The Sunnydale Region:
River
Malcolm Reynolds
Spike (Hells YEAH)
Darla (Come on, Ethan has always been the middleman and Darla always eats the middleman)

The Serenity Region:
Xander
Fred
Willow (I'm sorry, Tara, but its Willow)
Robin (If it was between Robin and Malcolm, it would TOTALLY be Malcolm but... Hammer is funny but all around jerk, so...)

Amanda said...

Oz
Jenny
SPIKE
Ethan
Xander
Fred
Willow
Wood

Anonymous said...

Sunnyhell:

Oz
Jenny
Spike! (I can't believe so many people are actually voting for Faith instead of Spikey...he's not only looking better but also funnier, crazier, meaner and everything else so much more than Faith (though I liked her too))
Darla

Serenity:

Gunn
The Master
Willow
Cpt. Hammer

dragonweaver said...

Like everyone else, I'm feeling the pain. Very tough choices.

The Sunnydale Region:

Oz
Jenny
Spike
Darla

The Serenity Region:

Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

Danielle said...

River
Malcolm
Faith
Darla
Xander
Fred
Tara (so unfair! Willow's gonna win, though. it's 7 years vs 2.5, sigh)
Wood

Counterpunch said...

-Oz
-Mal
-Spike
-Ethan
-Xander
-Fred
-Willow(you sick, sick bastard. I feel like I just murdered a child)
-Captain Hammer

itoy247 said...

So NOT fair to make us choose between Spike and Faith..but if i had to...well..sorry Faithy :P

Oz
Jenny
Spike (Spike, Spike, Spike a million time)
Darla

The Serenity Region:

Gunn
Fred
Tara
Captain Hammer

Michelle said...

The Sunnydale Region:

River

Malcolm Reynolds

Spike (This was sooooo hard)

Darla

The Serenity Region:

Charles Gunn (No contest)

Winifred "Fred" Burkle

Willow Rosenberg (I can't believe I went with Willow, but even if her story failed at times, she's still got more story under her belt than Tara did)

Captain Hammer (I still can't believe Wood beat Flutie)

Luthien said...

The Sunnydale Region:
River
Mal (disliked Jenny's character)
Faith (this was the hardest choice so far)
Darla

The Serenity Region:
Xander Harris
The Master
Willow
Captain Hammer

Belinda said...

Sunnydale region
Oz
Jenny Calendar
SPIKE (How can you even ask)
Darla
The serenity region
Xander
The master
Tara

Belinda said...

oh! Captain Hammer (never liked Wood)

Buffy Summers said...

Oz
Jenny
Faith
Darla
Xander
Fred
Willow
Wood

Jen Anderson said...

River
Mal
Spike
Darla
Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

Bitsy said...

Yeah! Post number 36, motherf^&*%*s! I have no idea what that means. On with the show!

- Oz because River is not a slayer I don't care what you think and la la la not listening.

- Mal because this isn't even contest. I hated Jenny before and I'll continue to hate her even after the Rapture comes to scoop her up and take her to mythical Jesus land.

- Faith because because I prefer my redeemed former murders with vay jay jays. It's just my way.

- Darla because I didn't even vote for Ethan the last time Sorry, I guess, Ethan, but not really.

- Charles Gunn because he actually had to be turned into a vampire in order to become a complete douche. Xander is just naturally that way.

- The Master because he's got punch bowl mouth.

- Tara because she wouldn't flay someone or get "addicted to magic" like a toolbox.

- Captain Hammer because Robin is still a wussy name.

hitnrun017 said...

Sunnydale:

-River
-Mal
-Faith
-Darla

Serenity:

-Xander (still angry he beat perfect Lilah)
-Fred
-Willow
-Hammer

Anonymous said...

Ozma!
mrs C
FAITH (im so bored of everyone worshipping spike jeeze)
Darla
xander coz of the speedos
Fred
DAAYUM! tough decision, Willow gotta support the red heads.
Robin. racial diversity in "buffy" is fun!

Buta Rose said...

Oz - I really want to say River, but the fact he's a former Scoob just makes me love him.

Jenny

Faith

Darla - Ethan NEVER should've beaten Fray. I still don't get how he did!

Xander

Fred

Tara - I think I just died inside a litle. *sob*

Hammer - I think he's an arogant twat, but at least I have some kind of emotion for the character.

Geraint! said...

Daniel osbourne
Jenny Calender
Faith Lehane
Darla (anyone know what her origional name was??)
Charles Gunn
winnifred burkle
Tara Mclay (because that episode with amy adams "family" made me cry)
Robin Wood

Anonymous said...

Sunnydale:

-OZ
-Mal
-Spike
-Darla

Serenity:

-Xander
-Fred
-Willow
-Wood

Ruthie said...

Brutal!
Sunnydale

River
Mal
Spike
Darla

Serenity

Xander
Fred(I lose, I had Kaylee going much farther)
Willow
Captain Hammer

Wyndam said...

- Oz
- Mal
- Spike (SO HARD to choose)
- Darla (Another toughie)
- Xander
- Fred
- Willow
- Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

- River
- Malcolm Reynolds
- Faith
- Darla

- Charles Gunn
- The Master
- Willow Rosenberg
- Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

The Sunnydale Region:

River
Malcolm Reynolds
Faith
Darla

The Serenity Region:

Xander Harris
Winifred "Fred" Burkle
Willow Rosenberg
Captain Hammer

Basket said...

oz
mal
spike
darla
xander
fred
tara(that was just....cruel)
captain hammer

Anonymous said...

Oz
Mal
Spike
Darla
Xander
Fred
Tara
Wood

Greer said...

Oz...obviously
Jenny!
Spike...I love him.
Darla, she's more interesting.
Gunn.
Fredikins.
Oh god, this is tough. But...Willow.
Robin Wood!

buffygroupie said...

This time was the easiest yet, for me.

Oz
Mal
Spike
Ethan
Xander
The Master
Willow
Hammer

angelvamp13 said...

Oz
Mal
Spike
Darla
Xander
Fred
Willow (but hard)
Robin

faile said...

River
Jenny
Faith
Darla
Xander
Fred
Tara
Hammer

Jennifer said...

Oz
Mal
Spike (love ya faith, but it's SPIKE)
Darla
Xander (charles, you aren't even close)
Fred (that was kinda hard...Master is pretty awesome)
Willow (sorry Tara)
Hammer

Thanks!

Anonymous said...

River
Malcolm Reynolds
Spike
Darla
Xander Harris
The Master
Willow Rosenberg
Robin Wood

Anonymous said...

The sunnydale region:
Oz
Jenny
Spike
Darla

The serenity region:
Xander Harries
Fred
Willow
Robin

Poniac said...

Oz
Malcolm
Faith
Ethan
Xander
The Master
Tara (&^%$@&^#@%#$@)
Wood

Anonymous said...

Oz
Mal
Spike
Darla
Gunn
Fred
Tara
Wood

Matt 2 of 3 said...

River
Mal
Spike
Darla
Xnader
Fred
Willow
Cap. Hammer

Chris said...

Sunnydale Region
River
Mal
Spike
Darla

Serenity Region
Xander
Fred
Tara
Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

Oz
Jenny
Faith
Darla
Gunn
Fred
Tara
Robin

Miranda said...

Eeep..


River
Mal
Spike (Brutal..)
Darla
Gunn
Fred
Willow
Hammer

Anonymous said...

Oz
Mal
Spike
Darla
Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

foreverxkisses said...

River 200%
Malcolm
Spike (This made me want to cry trying to choose)
Darla 100% So much more of a bad-ass hands down.
Xander (easiest choice ever!)
Fred=love
Tara, because she gave her life to quench the the writer's never ending thirst for damning those in love.
Captain Hammer, cause Wood was a fail.

AndrewCrossett said...

Sunnydale:
Oz (by a hair)
Mal
Ummmmmmm....Spike, I guess.
Darla

Serenity:
Xander
Fred
Willow (with love to Tara)
Captain Hammer

Nancy said...

Oz
Malcolm Reynolds
Spike
Darla

Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

mrscpttightpants said...

Oz
Captain TIghtpants
Spike
Darla
Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

Oz
Mal
spike
darla
Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer!

Andrew said...

Oz
Malcolm Reynolds
Spike
Ethan Rayne
Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

Grimoire said...

River
Malcolm Reynolds
Faith
Darla
Xander Harris
Winifred "Fred" Burkle
Tara MaClay
Captain Hammer

leavingtheeddy said...

my picks:
oz
malcolm
spike
darla
xander
fred
willow
captain hammer

Anarchangel said...

Oz
Mal
Spike
Darla

Xander (but close!)
Fred
Willow
Capt. Hammer.

cynthia said...

OZ!!!
Mal ( all the way)
Spike
Darla
Xander ( Hello! He is wearing an eyepatch!)
Fred
Willow (early Willow, not the uber witch one)
CAPTAIN HAMMER

Cherie said...

Sunnydale Region:

River Tam
Malcolm Reynolds
Spike
Darla

Serenity Region:

Xander Harris
Winifred "Fred" Burkle
Willow Rosenberg(sorry, Tara! love ya!)
Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

River
Mal
Faith
Darla
Xander
Fred
Tara
Wood

Anonymous said...

oz
malcolm
faith
darla
gunn (that's tough)
fred
willow
captain hammer

Anonymous said...

Sunnydale:
Oz
Malcolm Reynolds
Spike (that was agonizing!)
Darla

Serenity:
Charles Gunn (also agonizing)
Fred
Willow
Capt. Hammer

Michael said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

Sunnydale:

Oz
Malcolm
Spike
Darla

Serenity:

Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

Michael said...

Oz
Captain Reynolds
Spike
Darla

Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

Oz
Malcolm Reynolds
Spike
Ethan Rayne
Xander Harris
Winifred "Fred" Burkle
Willow Rosenberg
Principal Robin Wood

Anonymous said...

River
Malcolm Reynolds
Spike
Ethan Rayne
Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

River
Malcolm Reynolds
Spike
Darla
Xander Harris
Fred
Willow
Robin Wood

Jenny said...

The Sunnydale Region:
-Oz (So close, River!)
-Malcolm Reynolds
-Spike
-Ethan Rayne (Guess I'm one of the few who despises Darla)

The Serenity Region:
-Xander Harris (No contest.)
-Winifred "Fred" Burkle
-Willow Rosenberg
-Captain Hammer ("Thank you Hammer man.")

Trunkstheslayer6 said...

Sunnydale Region:
1-River
2-Jenny Calendar
3-(Oh god, that one's just evil)Faith
4-Darla

Serenity Region
1-Xander
2-The Master
3-Tara
4-Principal Wood

Lori said...

Oz
Mal
Spike
Ethan Rayne

Xander
Fred
Tara
Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

Here´s my bit:

River
Mal
Spike
Darla

Xander
Fred
Willow
Robin Wood

Majnun said...

River
Mal
Faith
Darla
Xander
Fred
Willow
Hammer

AthenaMuze said...

-Oz
-Mal
-Spike
-Darla
-Gunn
-Fred
-Willow
-Captain Hammer

Nitpicker said...

Oz
Mal
Faith
Ethan

Xander
Fred
Willow
Hammer

Anonymous said...

Sunnydale:
River
Malcolm Reynolds
Faith
Darla

Serenity:
Xander Harris
Winifred "Fred" Burkle
Willow Rosenberg
Captain Hammer

Amy said...

Sunnydale:
Oz, Malcom, Spike, Darla

Serenity:
Xander, Fred, Willow, Hammer

LA
Dr. Horrible, Rupert, Cordy, Angel

UK
Wesley, Anya, Buffy, Illyria

Anonymous said...

Oz!!!!!
Mal!!!!
Spike, obviously...
Ethan
Xander
Master
Willow
Capt. Hammer!!!!

Anonymous said...

Wow, some tough choises. Mostly from pairs which clearly won't make it all the way in though.

So, Sunnydale region:
-River (a bit of a headscratcher)
-Malcolm
-Spike (as nice as Faith was, Spike was essential)
-Darla (again, a toughie in the minor leage region)

Serenity region:
-Xander
-The Master (not a fan, but Fred wasn't that interesting either)
-Willow (nobrainer)
-Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

Oz
Mal
Spike
Darla
Xander
Fred
Willow
Hammer

Janna said...

Oz
Mal
Spike
Darla

Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

ben said...

River
Mal
Faith
Darla
Xander
Fred
Willow [poor Tara didn't have a chance]
Hammer

Micah said...

River
Mal
Faith
Ethan Rayne
Xander
The MAster
Willow
Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

River
Mal
Faith
Darla
Xander
Fred
Tara
Cap'n Hammer

Tyler A said...

- River.
- Mal.
- Spike.
- Darla.
- Xander.
- Fred!!
- Willow.
- Hammer.

Anonymous said...

River
Mal
Spike
Darla
Xander
Fred
Willow
Cap'n Hammer

Anonymous said...

Oz
Mal
Spike
Darla
Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

- OZ
-Mal
-Spike
-Darla
-Xander
-Fred
-Willow
- Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

-River
-Mal
-Faith
-Darla

-Xander
-Fred
-Willow
-Wood

sanitylapse said...

River
Mal
Darla
Gunn
The Master
Tara
Captain Hammer

nate said...

such a ridiculously good idea!!! love it!

sunnydale
oz hoists his leg on river
mal snaps jenny's neck (again)
spike out-cools faith
darla laughs off ethan

serenity
xander apologizes to gunn
fred outsmarts the master
willow disses her dead lover
captain hammer er...hammers robin

thanks!

Anonymous said...

River (hopefully the popular theory)
Mal
Faith!
Darla (sorry Ethan)
Xander
Fred (expect this round's biggest blowout)
Willow (love 'em both)
Wood, I guess

Anonymous said...

Oz
Mal
Spike
Darla
Xander
Fred
Willow
Wood

The explanations:
Oz was a perfect boyfriend: devoted, supportive, and ready to kill anyone who hurt Willow. He was also the character most likely to put things in perspective ("we survived... high school.").

Mal Reynolds: fiercely protective of his family, but also knows when to be silly. He's the one person you want at your back in a crisis.

Spike: tough choice here, but as gorgeous as Eliza is, half my BtVS quotes list is from Spike. Too smart and too cool to get caught up (as Faith did) in the whole "good" vs "evil" dichotomy, Spike only ever did what was awesome.

Darla: The first scene of the first episode set the stage for the entire series.

Xander: I never really connected with Gunn. Xander had few chances to be the hero, but those he did get he did well.

Fred: adorable nerd hero vs camp villain? No contest.

Willow vs Tara: These two were adorable together, and I think Willow did as much to bring out Tara's confidence as Oz had done for Willow. But alas for Tara, in direct comparison she will always be in Willow's shadow.

Wood: better at intelligence, romance, and even at being a hero than Hammer was.

Erica said...

- River
- Mal
- Spike
- Ethan
- Xander
- Fred
- Tara
- Capt. Hammer

Nina said...

River
Mal
Faith
Darla
Xander
Fred
Tara (with love to Willow)
Hammer

Cristie said...

Wow, some of these are hard. Here are my votes:

-River
-Mal
-Spike
-Darla
-Xander
-Fred
-Tara (but argh)
-Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

Oz
Mal
Spike
Ethan
Xander
Fred
Willow
Hammer

Anonymous said...

river
mal
spike
ethan
xander
fred
willow
hammer

Anonymous said...

The Sunnydale Region
River
Mal
Faith
Darla

The Serenity Region
Xander
Fred
Tara
Robin

yardrac said...

The Sunnydale Region
River
Captain Mal Reynolds
Spike
Ethan Rayne

The Serenity Region
Xander
Fred
Willow
Robin Wood (c'mon, only principal to survive Sunnydale High?)

Anonymous said...

River
Mal
Spike
Darla

Xander
Fred
Willow
Capt. Hammer

Tony said...

Sunnydale:

-River
-Jenny Calendar
-Faith
-Darla

Serenity

-Xander
-Fred
-Willow
-Captain Hammer

ian-michael89 said...

River
Malcolm
Faith
Darla
Xander
The Master
Willow
Captain Hammer!

Carly said...

Sunnydale Region:
-River
-Mal
-Spike
-Darla

Serenity Region
-Xander
-Fred
-Willow
-Captain Hammer

April_fool82 said...

i can't beleive i didn;t vote earlier when it was easier
*sigh*
ok
SUNNYDALE:
Oz - crap that was hard
Malcolm
hmmmm Spike
Darla

SERENITY
HARD CHOICE!! Zander by a whisker
Fred
Willow
Hammer

Veiriti said...

The Sunnydale Region:
Oz (he's sweet ;)))
Jenny Calendar
SPIKE, SPIKE, SPIKE (He's my champion!!!)
Darla (she is the best! Ethan Rayne sucks ;))

The Serenity Region:
Charles Gunn
Winifred "Fred" Burkle (I think the Master is stronger, but I love Fred more)
Willow Rosenberg
Captain Hammer (I hate Wood! LOL)

Gio said...

Oz
Mal
SPIKEEE!!
Darla

Xander
Fred
..hhmm....this is just CRUEL... don't know...I'm gonna go with Tara but it's hard..
HAMMER!!!

dekio said...

SUNNYDALE
Oz
Malcolm Reynolds
Spike
Ethan Rayne

SERENITY
Xander Harris
Winnifred "Fred" Burkle
Willow Rosenberg
Captain Hammer


funny how there were no Firefly characters in the Serenity region..

Anonymous said...

I'm gonna go for:
Oz
Malcolm Reynolds
Spike
Darla
And (these are tougher):
Xander Harris
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

Fearless said...

River
Mal
Spike
Darla

Gunn
Master
Willow
Robin Wood

Dr. Horrible
Rupert Giles
Cordy
Angel

Mayor Wilkins
Anya
Buffy
Illyria

Anonymous said...

Aaand my choices

Oz (this one was difficult!)
Malcolm Reynolds
Faith
Ethan Rayne
Xander Harris
Winifred "Fred" Burkle
Willow Rosenberg
Captain Hammer

munchlettebelle said...

Oh gosh. Some of these are super hard... I guess I'll go with:

River
Malcolm Reynolds
Spike
Darla

Xander Harris
Winifred "Fred" Burkle
Tara Maclay
Captain Hammer

Seriously, though? I had to choose between Faith and Spike? Willow/Tara was easier than that. Oz/River was a tough one too, just because the characters are so different.

Scott said...

Oz
Mal
Faith
Ethan
Xander
Fred
Willow
Hammer

Karnatos said...

Oz
Malcolm Reynolds
Spike
Darla
Xander Harris
Winifred "Fred" Burkle
Willow Rosenberg
Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

SUNNYDALE
River
Malcolm
Faith
Ethan Rayne

SERENITY
Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

Amanda said...

SUNNYDALE
Oz
Mal
Spike
Darla

SERENITY
Xander
Fred
Willow
Cpt. Hammer

The Groosalugg said...

SUNNYDALE

Oz
Malcolm Reynolds
Spike (close one!)
Darla

SERENITY
Xander
Fred
Willow (another close one!)
Robin Wood

erendis nasard said...

The Sunnydale Region:

River
Malcolm Reynolds
Faith
Darla

The Serenity Region:

Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

lavastar said...

River
Mal
Faith
Darla
Xande
Fred
Tara
Captain Hammer

Michelle said...

Oz
Mal
Spike
Darla
Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

Sunnydale Region:
River
Mal
Spike
Darla

Serenity Region:
Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

crystalsinger said...

I thought I was going crazy when I couldn't find how to vote. Then I looked in the comments... (duh)

Could we perhaps use an online poll thingy instead to make this easier??

Anyway, here's my choices for this round:

Sunnydale Region

Oz
Jenny
Faith
Darla

Serenity Region

Xander
Master
Tara (Willow's awesome, but Tara... MMmmmm...)
Wood

Anonymous said...

I just stumbled onto this today,so I'm not sure I really understand it, but here I go anyways.

If we are talking "They are in a horrible situation and I can only save one" I would pick Oz. If we are talking "who would win in a fist fight" that would be River.

I pick Mal over Jenny any day.

I pick Faith over Spike.

I pick Darla over Ethan.

I pick Xander over Charles

I pick Fred over the Master because I like her more, but the Master would most def win in an actual fist fight.

Wood over Hammer.

Anonymous said...

Oh and Willow over Tara

Anonymous said...

Choices are getting tougher now.

Sunnydale
River
Mal
Faith
Darla

Serenity
Xander
Fred
Willow
Hammer

Ktrain12 said...

Sunnydale:
Oz
Malcolm Reynolds
Spike
Darla

Serenity
Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

Nathaniel Cornstalk said...

Oz (though he has a snowball's chance in hell of winning)
Mal
Faith
Ethan Rayne
Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

River
Mal
spike
darla
xander
fred
willow
captain hammer

tarabot said...

River
Mal
Faith
Darla
Xander
Fred
Tara (obviously)
Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

River; Mal; Spike; Darla; Xander; Fred; Willow; Capt. Hammer.

Offek said...

Oz
Jenny
Faith
Darla
Xander
Willow
Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

River
Jenny
Faith
Ethan
Gunn
The Master
Tara
Hammer!!!

Beg2Diffr said...

Sunnydale Region
Oz
Mal
Spike
Darla

Serenity Region
Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

Sunnydale Region:
Oz
Malcolm Reynolds
Faith
Ethan Rayne

Serenity Region:
Xander Harris
Winifred "Fred" Burkle
Willoe Rosenburg
Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

The Sunnydale Region
Oz
Jenny Calender
SPIKE
Darla

The Serenity Region
Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain

Dodd said...

Oz
Malcolm Reynolds
Spike
Darla

Xander Harris
The Master
Willow Rosenberg
Captain Hammer

Natalia said...

River
Mal Reynolds
Spike (you are cruel guys!!!)
Darla

Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

The Cheshire Pooh said...

river
reynolds
faith
darla
xander
the master
willow
Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

River
Malcom
Spike
Darla

Zander
Fred
Willow
Principal Wood

Nolan said...

Oz (this one was just cruel)
Malcolm Reynolds
Spike
Darla

Xander (toughie)
Fred
Tara (ugh what, too hard)
Captain Hammer

Emily said...

oz, but it was close
mal
spike
darla
gunn
fred (duh!)
willow (i may cry about it, though)
captain hammer

Anonymous said...

Oz
Malcom Reynolds
Faith
Darla
Xander Harris
Winifred "Fred" Burkle
Willow Rosenberg
Captain Hammer

YAY I love this!

Nate said...

This is brutal.

Sunnydale Region:
Oz
Malcolm Reynolds
Faith
Darla

Serenity Region:
Xander Harris
Winifred Burkle
Willow Rosenberg
Principal Robin Wood

Ben Nadler said...

Sunydale:
Oz
Malcolm Reynolds
Spike
Darla

Serenity:
Charles Gunn
Winifred Burkle
Williow Rosenberg
Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

Sunnydale Region:

River
Mal
Faith
Darla

Serenity Region:

Gunn
Fred
Willow
Hammer

Anonymous said...

The Sunnydale Region:
Oz
Malcom Reynolds
Spike
Darla

The Serenity Region:
Xander Harris
Winifred "Fred" Burkle
Willow Rosenberg
Captain Hammer

ACollinsVampire said...

Oz
Jenny
Faith
Ethan
Xander
Fred
Willow
Wood

Anonymous said...

Sunnydale Region:
- Oz
- Captain Tightpants
- Spike
- Darla

Serenity Region:
- Xander
- Fred
- Tara (out of continuing bitterness over the "magic=drugs" storyline)
- Principal Wood

Christine said...

River
Malcolm Reynolds
Spike
Darla

Xander
Winifred
Tara
Captain Hamer

Anonymous said...

The Sunnydale Region

Oz v. River: River

Jenny Calendar v. Malcolm Reynolds: Malcolm Reynolds

Faith v. Spike: Spike

Darla v. Ethan Rayne: Darla

The Serenity Region:

Xander Harris v. Charles Gunn: Xander Harris

Fred Burkle v. The Master: Fred Burkle

Willow Rosenberg v. Tara MaClay: Willow Rosenberg

Principal Robin Wood v. Captain Hammer: Captain Hammer

Jonathan said...

Sunnydale Region:
Oz
Malcolm
Spike
Darla

Serenity Region:
Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

dudecastle said...

Sunnydale:
River
Mal
Faith
Darla

Serenity:
Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

Why are there no Dollhouse characters included?

Surrea said...

I'm sad I missed the initial round of voting...

- River
- Jenny Calendar
- Spike
- Ethan Rayne
- Xander Harris
- Winifred "Fred" Burkle
- Willow Rosenburg (Oh that one was painful)
- Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

Oz
Malcolm
Spike of course, sorry Faith
Darla
Xander
Fred
Willow
Capt. Hammer

Anonymous said...

Ok, let's see:
-Oz
-Jenny
-Can't I choose both? Grr...It's gonna have to be Spike.
-Darla
-Xander
-Fred
-Tara
-Wood

celebrity said...

River
Mal
Spike
Darla

Xander
Fred
Willow
Robin Wood

Anonymous said...

-River
-Jenny
-Faith
-Darla
-Xander
-Fred
-Tara
-Captain Hammer

Jennifer said...

- Oz
- Mal
- Faith
- Ethan

- Xander
- Fred
- Willow
- Wood

Anonymous said...

Sunnydale:
Oz
Mal
Faith, you evil bastards
Darla, sorry bb

Serenity:
Xander, guh I hate this
Fred
Willow :(
Captain Hammer

fighttorflightt said...

Oz
Jenny
Faith
Darla
Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

Krys said...

Oz
Mal
Spike
Darla
Xander
Fred
Willow
Hammer

Sarah said...

oh my.

-oz
-jenny
-spike
-darla

-charles
-fred
-willow
-hammer (wood is so beyond annoying)

Chapel_Perilous said...

Oz
Mal
Spike
Ethan
Xander
Fred
Willow
Hammer

Michael said...

The Serenity Region:
River
Mal
Spike
Darla

The Serenity Region:
Xander
Fred
Willow
Captain Hammer

Anonymous said...

Sunnydale:
River
Jenny Calender
Faith
Darla

Serenity:
Charles Gunn
Fred Burkle
Willow Rosenburg
Captain Hammer

Tara said...

Ok, voting has ended for this round. On to the final part of Round 2!

J said...

oz
mal
spike
ethan
xander
fred
willow
hammer

ta very